4/27/ · This paper presents a critique of a qualitative research article titled: ‘Perceived support from healthcare practitioners among adults with type 2 diabetes’ (Oftedal et al, ) (appendix 1). To enable the critique of this article the Caldwell critiquing tool () will be utilized. (Appendix 2) CRITIQUE EXAMPLE – JOURNAL ARTICLE. REVIEW OF A JOURNAL ARTICLE: AN EXAMPLE (Unfortunately, I don’t have the name of the reviewer.) Bibliography. Author, F. (). Effects of classroom testing by microcomputer. Journal of ABCDE, 99(9), Problem research on this kind of program. Significant results were noted in the results of this study, but there are limitations to these findings. First, the sample size was small. Out of incoming students who were invited to participate, only 32 students completed the pre- and post- anxiety inventory. WithFile Size: KB
How to Critique an Article in 3 Steps (with Example) | EssayPro
We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. Critique of A Qualitative Research Article: The Experience of Acupuncture for Treatment of Substantial Dependence, by Kunsook Song Bernstein Don't use plagiarized sources. The purpose of the study, the research design and methods used and the findings and conclusions were briefly but adequately explained in the abstract. However, critiquing research articles example, literature synthesis is not provided.
Nonetheless, the abstract is able to distinguish the specific purpose identified for the research and how the actual procedures and findings matched the problem. While the author recognizes the dearth of materials on the subject matter, she comes to this study from a number of conceptual perspectives, most prominent of which are concepts of traditional Chinese medicine and acupuncture treatment of substance abuse.
A cursory study of related materials that were available at the time of the research reveals that the author has made an exhaustive presentation of theories and findings of previous researches. The author presents an integrative literature review and gives a critical analysis of the significance, critiquing research articles example, methods, and inadequacies of previous researches on the use of acupuncture as an alternative treatment mode to substance abuse.
Discussing concepts of traditional Chinese medicine and the Critiquing research articles example medical theory of substance abuse helped to broaden the focus. Overall, the literature review is written from an interpretive definitive voice e. they reported, they claimed as a dimensional analysis. While the critiquing research articles example on literature review in the introduction is well organized, it does not, however, effectively establish the framework for the way in which the researcher proposes to achieve the purpose of the study.
The proposed research method, i. phenomenological investigation, critiquing research articles example, and the theoretical foundations of phenomenological tradition as a paradigm in qualitative studies are not explained. The study hinges on the importance of studying the facets of substance abuse and of finding ways to improve efforts for prevention and control. Thus, the author succinctly establishes the significance of her investigation.
While the report does not have any explanation on the philosophical background or assumptions of phenomenological theory as a research method, the author explicitly identified the source of the theoretical framework, enumerated the steps entailed in this method and justified its critiquing research articles example as being appropriate to the purpose of the study.
Typical of qualitative studies, the participants of the study were chosen from among a group of individuals who match the criteria and who can contribute to the purposes of the investigation. The researcher claims that redundancy was used as the primary criterion in sample selection which implies that homogeneity was achieved, critiquing research articles example. Twelve patients of a detoxification and rehabilitation unit for substance and gambling addictions were recommended by a volunteer informant.
The final sample size was eight subjects who were chosen after having been interviewed by the researcher. Choosing only those patients who have not tried acupuncture as a treatment mode is commendable as it contributed to the reliability of the results.
Nonetheless, the small sample size is acceptable for a pioneering study such as this. Interviewing is a central method in phenomenological studies. This was used by the researcher to explore the experiences of the participants during acupuncture treatment.
How the interview was conducted was sufficiently explained by the author but she does not elaborate on the specific questions asked during the interview.
The author mentioned she used Giorgi modification method for data analysis and enumerated the steps in accordance to this method but does not explicitly describe the approaches to coding the data and condensing the data in meaningful form. The phenomenological method was very appropriate for the study because this particular qualitative method is often used in situations with a strong emotional element, critiquing research articles example it emphasizes experience above thought Giorgi, Overall, the aspects of the research design, critiquing research articles example, data collection and analysis remain true to the rules and assumptions of qualitative research.
At this juncture, it should be pointed out that other design elements could have been incorporated to strengthen the study. For example, a longitudinal perspective could produce more solid evidences on the effectiveness of acupuncture as a treatment to substance abuse, although this was properly acknowledged by the researcher at critiquing research articles example end of the report.
Bernstein was successful in integrating theories and findings of previous researches in her discussion of results. She underscores that her findings indicate that acupuncture can be viewed as a complex phenomenon and further studies should be conducted. Although her study was limited in sample size and one-time interview, her preliminary findings are consistent with the related literature and buttress the use of acupuncture as a treatment to substance abuse.
Although validity and reliability are concepts which do not translate well to a qualitative paradigm, the researcher strived to address validity and reliability issues through a number of steps.
In sampling, she availed of the critiquing research articles example of a psychiatrist who determined the diagnosis based on DSM-IV criteria and validated the diagnosis of substance dependence. The researcher sought to ensure credibility of the volunteer informant by choosing someone who has more than 10 years experience in the field of substance abuse and independence.
She used an external auditors, i. other mental health clinicians but as to how many is not indicatedfor critique of the synthesized insights and results. Basing from the intrinsic limitations of the study, Bernstein lists a number of recommendations to follow up her research among which is the conduct of related studies that either strengthen data collection techniques or broaden the time and setting of the study.
The significance of this study as implied by the researcher in her concluding statements lies in its contribution to knowledge the dimensions of substance abuse and on acupuncture as a treatment modality in order to aid health care providers in incorporating alternative approaches to their practices. Overall, the research reflects consistency between procedure, data critiquing research articles example interpretation.
The author was able to make reasonable and founded interpretations from her findings. The researcher adequately applied the principles of qualitative research to come out with a valid and reliable study. References: Bersntein, K. S The experience of acupuncture for treatment of substance dependence. Journal of Nursing Scholarship. Fall v32 i3 p Giorgi, A, critiquing research articles example. In: Giorgi A ed. Phenomenology and Psychological Research.
Pittsburgh, PA: Duquesne Critiquing research articles example, Cite this Critique of A Qualitative Research Critique of A Qualitative Research. Critique of A Qualitative Research. Accessed April 24, This is just a sample. You can get your custom paper from our expert writers. All you need to do is fill out a short form and submit an order. See Pricing. What's Your Topic? Hire a Professional Writer Now.
The input space is limited by symbols. What's Your Deadline? How Many Pages? Sign Up and See Pricing, critiquing research articles example. Please enter valid email. Back Get Offer. Write my paper. Deadline: 2 days left. Similar Categories:. Research Paper. Paper Type: Essay. Pages: 5 words. Download Paper : Views: Get Your Custom Essay on. How to Avoid Plagiarism. Use multiple resourses when assembling your essay Get help form professional writers when not sure you can do it yourself Use Plagiarism Checker to double check your essay Do not copy and paste free to download essays Get plagiarism free essay.
Not Finding What You Need? Search for essay samples now. Please indicate where to send you the sample or.
Send Me The Sample By clicking Send Me The Sample you agree on the terms and conditions of our service. We'll not send you spam or irrelevant messages, critiquing research articles example. Go To My Inbox. All you need to do is fill out a short critiquing research articles example and submit an order Check out the form.
Haven't found the Essay You Want? Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email. Topic: Critique of A Qualitative Research send By clicking "Send", you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We'll occasionally send you account related and promo emails.
How to analyze a research article for Critique 2 (3 of 3)
, time: 17:46Critique of A Qualitative Research Example | Graduateway
CRITIQUE EXAMPLE – JOURNAL ARTICLE. REVIEW OF A JOURNAL ARTICLE: AN EXAMPLE (Unfortunately, I don’t have the name of the reviewer.) Bibliography. Author, F. (). Effects of classroom testing by microcomputer. Journal of ABCDE, 99(9), Problem Critiquing Research Articles_Nov _V CRITIQUING RESEARCH ARTICLES • Use of apparatus: If any apparatus were used, it should be briefly identified and described, and its function in the research explained. If any apparatus were obtained or donated by a commercial source, this must be stated. • Procedure: Each step in the research procedure should be explained. This includes any instructions to 11/8/ · Critique of A Qualitative Research. Just from $13,9/Page. Get custom paper. The study has a clear title and abstract statements. The purpose of the study, the research design and methods used and the findings and conclusions were briefly but adequately explained in the abstract. However, literature synthesis is not provided
No comments:
Post a Comment